Policing minister wants stop and search ramped up despite racial profiling fears – UK politics live | Politics
Minister says stop and search to be ramped up, dismissing concerns about disproportionate targeting of black men
Good morning. It would be nice to think that the government is not entirely focused on re-election, and that not all decisions are being made with partisan considerations to the fore, but it can be hard to sustain that view after a glance at the papers. Today the government has put two issues on the table – both of which might appeal to a Tory election strategist hoping to find something (anything?) that might create a dividing line with Labour.
First, sex education. Gillian Keegan, the education secretary, is expected to publish plans tomorrow, but right-leaning papers have been briefed that the rules for schools in England will be stricter and that they will be told not to teach pupils about gender identity issues.
Our story, by Richard Adams and Pippa Crerar, is here.
The advantage of briefing out a story like this in advance, from the government’s point of view, is that reports get written up on the basis of what sources tell reporters, not on the basis of what a document actually says. But the disadvantage is that this makes it easy for Labour to say it won’t comment until it has seen the detail, but which time the media caravan will have moved on.
And, second, there is an announcement about ramping up stop and search to counter knife crime.
Chris Philp, the policing minister, has been giving interviews about this topic this morning and he told LBC:
I’d like to see officers, of course, use the power lawfully and also respectfully, but it does need to be used more to protect the public and particularly the kind of young men who often end up being victims of knife crime.
When it was put to him that in the past stop and search has been used disproportionately against young black men, he replied:
The sad truth is that young black men are disproportionately victims of knife crime and we’re doing this as much to protect them as anything else.
He also said that stop and search success rates typically have a success rate of 25 to 30%.
That percentage is pretty much the same across something to within 1% across all ethnicities so that gives me quite a high degree of confidence that police are not unreasonably picking on particular parts of the community.
Philp was also on the Today programme where Emma Barnett, who has just joined the programme as a presenter, pointed out that when Theresa May was home secretary she restricted the use of stop and search. She asked why the government was performing a U-turn. In response, Philp said stop and search rates in London have fallen by 44% in the past two years. When Barnett put it to him that May’s policy had failed, Philp dodged the question.
Talking of Theresa May, there was some speculation last night that Labour might announce another defector in time for PMQs today. May told Bethany Dawson from Politico that it would not be her.
Asked if she would stand again as a Conservative, Theresa May tonight said “I am a Conservative, I would stand again as a Conservative,” largely quashing the excitement of people thinking of the funniest option for defection.
Labour sources are saying that hacks on defector watch should stand down today. But the very fact that it did not seem totally absurd for a reporter to ask a former PM if they would defect to another party does say something about the state of Rishi Sunak’s Conservative party.
Here is the agenda for the day.
9.30am: Brian Bell, chair of the Migration Advisory Committee, and other migration experts give evidence to the Commons home affairs committee.
10am: Arlene Foster, the former Northern Ireland first minister, gives evidence to the UK Covid inquiry in Belfast.
12pm: Rishi Sunak faces Keir Starmer at PMQs.
After 12.45pm: MPs begin the first day of the debate on the remaining stages of the criminal justice bill.
3pm: Michael Tomlinson, the minister for illegal migration, gives evidence to the joint committee on human rights.
For technical reasons we are not using the ‘send us a message’ feature any more, and if you want to contact me, please post a message below the line (BTL) or message me on X (Twitter). I can’t read all the messages BTL, but if you put “Andrew” in a message aimed at me, I am more likely to see it because I search for posts containing that word. If you want to flag something up urgently, it is best to use X; I’ll see something addressed to @AndrewSparrow very quickly. I find it very helpful when readers point out mistakes, even minor typos (no error is too small to correct). And I find your questions very interesting too. I can’t promise to reply to them all, but I will try to reply to as many as I can, either BTL or sometimes in the blog.
Key events
The Law Society has issued this statement about today’s decision to delay some court hearings because of prison overcrowding.
We have been made aware that from today, the lord chancellor is triggering an emergency measure, Operation Early Dawn, to deal with the worsening problem of the prison population.
Many magistrates’ court cases will be delayed. Practitioners will not know if their clients’ cases will be delayed for sure until they get there.
This particular impact will be caused by a triage process for defendants being transferred from police custody suites to the magistrates courts and then likely to be transferred to prison. We understand priority will be given to defendants in the most serious cases. We understand that defendants who are not prioritised will be released on police bail.
We are awaiting further urgent information from HMCTS and MoJ to clarify the practical implications of this decision, including how they will deal with the issue of the wasted costs members may incur in these circumstances.
We will update members in due course.
Court hearings delayed as Ministry of Justice slows proceedings due to prison overcrowding
Some court hearings in England are going to be delayed because of prison overcrowding, the BBC is reporting. In their story Chris Mason and Jennifer McKiernan report:
Courts in England in areas with a lack of prison places will be affected for around a week.
A solicitors’ group said many magistrates’ court cases will be affected as officials decide which defendants will be prioritised.
The move, called Operation Early Dawn, is expected to impact courts in England for around a week in regions where there is a lack of prison places.
The Ministry of Justice told the BBC that the government is creating thousands more prison places to meet demand. The Criminal Law Solicitors Association said:
We are appalled of the state of our criminal justice system and have been campaigning on this from our inception and whilst we recognise the need for some action, this is a symptom of a systemic problem caused by more than 40 years of neglect of our criminal justice system.
Chris Philp, the policing minister, told Sky News this morning that equipment allowing the police to scan people for knives at a distance is almost ready to be rolled out. He explained:
A police officer could scan people walking down the street at a distance of six or 10 feet to see if they’re carrying a knife.
So scanning large numbers of people, that’s not ready for deployment today, but I’m hoping by the end of this year it can be deployed experimentally or in a test way.
Jeremy Hunt and Mel Stride warn against benefits ‘lifestyle choice’
Jeremy Hunt, the chancellor, and Mel Stride, the work and pensions secretary, have suggested that too many people are claiming unemployment benefit as a lifestyle choice in a joint article published in the Times. Matthew Weaver has the story here.
The Labour party has not press released anything about stop and search or sex education this morning, but it is attacking the government’s record on sewage. In a response to a BBC story revealing that millions of litres of raw sewage were pumped into Lake Windemere in February, because a water company took 10 hours to address a problem with a broken pump, Steve Reed, the shadow environment secretary, said:
The Conservatives just folded their arms and looked the other way while United Utilities pumped a tidal wave of raw sewage into Britain’s most beautiful lake.
It’s time for change.
The next Labour government will put the water companies under special measures to force United Utilities to clean up their toxic mess.
We will give the regulator tough new powers to make law-breaking water bosses face criminal charges and ban the payment of their multi-million pound bonuses until they clean up their toxic filth.
Curbs on sex education use pupils as ‘political football’, school leaders say
School leaders have accused the government of using children as “a political football” over its proposals to restrict sex education lessons in England, Richard Adams reports.
Minister says stop and search to be ramped up, dismissing concerns about disproportionate targeting of black men
Good morning. It would be nice to think that the government is not entirely focused on re-election, and that not all decisions are being made with partisan considerations to the fore, but it can be hard to sustain that view after a glance at the papers. Today the government has put two issues on the table – both of which might appeal to a Tory election strategist hoping to find something (anything?) that might create a dividing line with Labour.
First, sex education. Gillian Keegan, the education secretary, is expected to publish plans tomorrow, but right-leaning papers have been briefed that the rules for schools in England will be stricter and that they will be told not to teach pupils about gender identity issues.
Our story, by Richard Adams and Pippa Crerar, is here.
The advantage of briefing out a story like this in advance, from the government’s point of view, is that reports get written up on the basis of what sources tell reporters, not on the basis of what a document actually says. But the disadvantage is that this makes it easy for Labour to say it won’t comment until it has seen the detail, but which time the media caravan will have moved on.
And, second, there is an announcement about ramping up stop and search to counter knife crime.
Chris Philp, the policing minister, has been giving interviews about this topic this morning and he told LBC:
I’d like to see officers, of course, use the power lawfully and also respectfully, but it does need to be used more to protect the public and particularly the kind of young men who often end up being victims of knife crime.
When it was put to him that in the past stop and search has been used disproportionately against young black men, he replied:
The sad truth is that young black men are disproportionately victims of knife crime and we’re doing this as much to protect them as anything else.
He also said that stop and search success rates typically have a success rate of 25 to 30%.
That percentage is pretty much the same across something to within 1% across all ethnicities so that gives me quite a high degree of confidence that police are not unreasonably picking on particular parts of the community.
Philp was also on the Today programme where Emma Barnett, who has just joined the programme as a presenter, pointed out that when Theresa May was home secretary she restricted the use of stop and search. She asked why the government was performing a U-turn. In response, Philp said stop and search rates in London have fallen by 44% in the past two years. When Barnett put it to him that May’s policy had failed, Philp dodged the question.
Talking of Theresa May, there was some speculation last night that Labour might announce another defector in time for PMQs today. May told Bethany Dawson from Politico that it would not be her.
Asked if she would stand again as a Conservative, Theresa May tonight said “I am a Conservative, I would stand again as a Conservative,” largely quashing the excitement of people thinking of the funniest option for defection.
Labour sources are saying that hacks on defector watch should stand down today. But the very fact that it did not seem totally absurd for a reporter to ask a former PM if they would defect to another party does say something about the state of Rishi Sunak’s Conservative party.
Here is the agenda for the day.
9.30am: Brian Bell, chair of the Migration Advisory Committee, and other migration experts give evidence to the Commons home affairs committee.
10am: Arlene Foster, the former Northern Ireland first minister, gives evidence to the UK Covid inquiry in Belfast.
12pm: Rishi Sunak faces Keir Starmer at PMQs.
After 12.45pm: MPs begin the first day of the debate on the remaining stages of the criminal justice bill.
3pm: Michael Tomlinson, the minister for illegal migration, gives evidence to the joint committee on human rights.
For technical reasons we are not using the ‘send us a message’ feature any more, and if you want to contact me, please post a message below the line (BTL) or message me on X (Twitter). I can’t read all the messages BTL, but if you put “Andrew” in a message aimed at me, I am more likely to see it because I search for posts containing that word. If you want to flag something up urgently, it is best to use X; I’ll see something addressed to @AndrewSparrow very quickly. I find it very helpful when readers point out mistakes, even minor typos (no error is too small to correct). And I find your questions very interesting too. I can’t promise to reply to them all, but I will try to reply to as many as I can, either BTL or sometimes in the blog.